Last night I had the opportunity to hang out with my usual crew of wine nerd and imbibe some very nice and beautiful Washington wines. Typically we go through a bottles in a sitting and have found very few losers in the world of Washington. Tonight we picked three bottles we haven't had, the
2004 Three Rivers Champoux Cabernet Sauvignon,
2004 Andrew Will Ciel du Cheval Red, and the
2000 Col Solare Red.

The first wine on deck we had was the
2004 Three Rivers Cab. I picked up this wine not too long ago at a well respected and incredibly well stocked shop in Richmond, VA, J. Emersons, upon the suggestion of a few of the employees. It was pretty pricey, about $50 a bottle, but came from a great vineyard and was highly touted by all around the shop. Upon arriving I popped an poured a glass, letting it sit out for about an hour or so to get its footing.
Nose: When I came back, it had a great nose of red fruit, blueberries, heavy dark chocolate, a little manure, and dirt. I love the earthiness of this effort, especially compared to the sugarfied, oak driven action to its neighbors to the south. As it unfolded, I found more and more red fruit, a lot of all types of milk and dark chocolate througout, with the dirty, earthy component really taking hold. Overall a great nose.
Taste: At the beginning with a little air time, it came hard and heavy like the nose with the red cherries and strawberries, dirt and chocolate. The tannins were not very pronounced, although there was a good amount of structuring and cleanliness of the flavors. This wine was basically taking a bowl of chocolate covered cherries, strawberries, and cranberries, dropping the entire thing in some nice deep dark dirt, and then taking a bite. A little simplistic at first, it started to come together nicely with a lot of elegant chocolate and deep earth flavors. The only real downer is that the mouthfeel just want up to snuff, especially when compared with a lot of other wines at this pricepoint. It felt very very delicate and thin on the palate, really too racy for its own good. It did have a good amount of acidity, which was nice, but overall couldn't save the thinner mouthfeel.
Overall: This wine I think would be a perfect table wine, although I think it is a little mispriced. I can find a lot of what I like in this effort at a lower price point, so I would have to give it an overall pass.
87 Points
The second wine on deck was the
Andrew Will 2004 Ciel du Cheval Vineyards Red Wine. It is a single vineyard blend, something that Andrew Will is known for, of 48% merlot, 30% Cab Franc, 15% Cabernet Sauvignon, and 7% Petit Verdot. This wine hales from one of the best areas in Washington, the Red Mountain AVA, and I was able to find this at Total Wine and More in Newport News, VA at closeout for $40.00. The press on this wine was not nearly as glowing as many other efforts from this vintner, garnering on average rating in the high 80's, which for a wine rolling in at aroudn $60 bucks retail, many would pass on. Man are those guys wrong.
Nose: This wine was kind of the bigger, more polished, and deeper brother of the Three Rivers Cab we had earlier. It was amazingly polished nose, with great amounts of red and black fruit, dark dark dark chocolate, a little manure, great amounts of loamy undergrowthy earth, and ended with a nice tinge of quality milk and dark chocolate. Very, very delectable nose.
Taste: This wine is tremendous, straight up. Compared to the cab earlier, this is what the cab was trying to be but just couldn't cut the mustard. Heavy amounts of polish on this effort, firm but very rounded tannins, heavy amounts of earth and bitter dark chocolate, sour cherries, back end of strawberry, cassis, licorace, nice red cabbage, vegetal components, a little gamey/meaty action, and had a long long finish of dark chocolate and nice beautiful cassis and sour cherries. The mouthfeel was very thick, almost viscious, but didn't just sit there and plump itself on my tongue. It was very polished, draping itself over my palate, almost making sure I tasted every last bit of it. Great, great wine.
Overall: In comparison to the earlier wine and on its own, this wine is a killer value even at $60. This wine has a lot of Old World love to it, but with enough fruit to keep everyone happy. Amazing effort from a vintage that a lot of people were not as high on as the 2003 efforts.
94 Points.
Pulling up the rear of the tasting is the
2000 Col Solare Red Wine. Col Solare is the joint project between Chateau Ste. Michelle and Tuscan winemaker Marchese Antinori. I picked this little wine up at the best shop in Williamsburg, the Cheese Shop in Merchants Square. This was the last bottle of the 2000 vintage in the shop, and at $30, I figured I would give it a whirl. It is made up primarily of of Cabernet (upwards of 70%), with the rest of the blend being Merlot and Syrah.
Nose: Given this blind, I would say Barolo, Barolo, Barolo every time including Sunday. Has such scent of burnt rubber and the inside of a sweaty winter jacket, which I for some reason get whenever I encounter Sango or Nebbiolo. Very nice red and black fruit tandem taking hold throughout the beginning, and has a lot of New World fruitiness and sweetness to it, especially when compared to the other wines. Overall, much more in the vain of a California Barolo lovechild more than anything.
Taste: Again you can tell this has some definite Italian flair to it with the extreme resemblence to Barolo, Tuscanos, and Barbarescos in both the mouthfeel and overall taste. I get a huge amount of Asian spices, black fruit, some strawberry, and a little bit of rubber skid mark, burnt rubber action. Definitely more fruit forward than the other two wines though, with not nearly as much earth or density as the previous two wines. A little too sugarfied, but has a nice mouthfeel and a decently long finish of black fruit and heavy asian spices and rubber.
Overall: If you want to see how Italy would be in Washington, this is the wine. Very interesting to say the least and not at all what I expected going into it. Nice ripe fruit, with heavy Italian love and flair throughout, I would definitely suggest this to anyone who loves Super Tuscans and has never had a Washington wine. To me, this is not my favorite, being a little to fruit foward and the rubber aspects did get to me, but an overall good wine.
88 Points.
If you guys have any suggestions or requests, please feel free to contact me anytime.